274: How The Profit First Policy Method Changed Brandon Neely’s Life

Wealth Without Bay Street

274: How The Profit First Policy Method Changed Brandon Neely’s Life

00:00 / 00:43:02

Wealth On Main Street 274: How The Profit First Policy Method Changed Brandon Neely’s Life

What if your biggest financial breakthrough didn’t come from Wall Street, but from a coffee shop flood?

In a recent episode of Wealth On Main Street, Richard Canfield and Jayson Lowe sat down with Brandon Neely, an entrepreneur, Profit First Professional, and the co-host of Wealth Wisdom Financial Podcast with his wife Amanda Neely, to talk about the moment his world flipped and how it pushed him to redefine wealth, purpose, and legacy.

Brandon’s journey from slinging coffee at Overflow Coffee Bar in Chicago to becoming a Profit First Professional and co-host of the Wealth Wisdom Financial Podcast is nothing short of inspiring.

More than a story of resilience, his path is a playbook for any entrepreneur who wants to take control of their finances, live their values, and create lasting financial independence.

Profit First and Infinite Banking can change your financial life!

The Flood That Sparked Financial Clarity

Sometimes your greatest transformation begins with a disaster. For Brandon, it was a literal flood that wrecked his café.

But this wasn’t the end—it was the turning point.

Running Overflow Coffee Bar for nearly a decade, Brandon and his wife Amanda weren’t just brewing coffee. They were building a mission-driven business focused on community, connection, and ethical economics.

Yet behind the scenes, financial stress loomed. “We were living off of tips from the tip jar, and the staff made more than we did,” Brandon recalls.

Then came the storm, literally. Their café’s roof was being repaired when a heavy rainstorm hit. “We run to the store and we're in water… it was bad,” Brandon shares. And yet, this moment of chaos became one of clarity.

Thanks to the Infinite Banking Concept (IBC), which they had implemented years prior after watching the documentary Banking With Life, Brandon had access to capital. “Because of my policies, I was able to overcome the flood and sell the business,” he explains.

“My biggest risk was me. My biggest investment was me.”

This experience drilled in a core truth: You can’t control external crises, but you can control how prepared you are for them. Preparation starts with systems that honor your role as both investor and investment.

Infinite Banking gave Brandon the leverage he needed, not just to stay afloat, but to pivot into a new purpose.

Why Profit First Isn’t Just a System—It’s a Mindset Shift

You’ve probably heard the phrase “pay yourself first,” but how many entrepreneurs actually do it?

Brandon didn’t—at least not at the start. He and Amanda were “eating ramen all day long” and giving every dollar to their staff, suppliers, and creditors before thinking about their own financial well-being.

That all changed when they stumbled upon the Profit First podcast by Mike Michalowicz. It was 2017, and they were finally ready to do something different. They couldn’t afford fancy coaching, but a free book offer from the podcast caught their attention. “I wrote a review, got the book, wrapped it, and gave it to my wife for Christmas,” Brandon says with a laugh.

That one gift became the seed of their new financial system.

For Brandon, Profit First wasn’t just about setting up buckets and percentages—it was about reclaiming agency.

“Most people are sleepwalking,” he says. “They say they have ‘a guy,’ but they’re not their own guy.” And that’s the real power of the Profit First model. It forces you to stop being passive with your money. It insists that you prioritize your own stability before anyone else’s bottom line.

He now uses the system religiously, even embedding parts of it into his Infinite Banking strategy. “We put our tax hold account in a policy,” he says.

That means even money reserved for taxes is working for them, compounding quietly in the background while still being available when needed.

This hybrid approach—Profit First for cash flow, Infinite Banking for storage and leverage—is what helped Brandon and Amanda break the cycle of financial anxiety. It all started with one shift: realizing that business owners deserve to profit first, not last.

How Infinite Banking Became the Neelys’ Financial Backbone

While Profit First helped them take control of cash flow, Infinite Banking gave them power over capital—and peace of mind in the process. After watching Banking With Life, Brandon and Amanda were struck by one simple question:

“Why would I put money into other people’s businesses and not my own?”

This was their lightbulb moment. They began small, starting with a $400/month policy. “That was a lot for us,” Brandon admits. But it was the beginning of what he now calls “the overflow principle.” Each policy became not just a savings vehicle, but a declaration of intent: to bet on themselves.

As their income grew, so did their commitment. Now, they tithe more than they used to earn, and they’ve used policies to buy offices, fund emergencies, and even set up legacy planning for their son.

Brandon is especially passionate about this point. “Your biggest investment is you,” he emphasizes.

Infinite Banking isn’t about getting rich overnight. It’s about long-term control, leverage, and resilience.

When your capital lives inside a properly structured whole life policy, you’re never at the mercy of the banks, the IRS, or a credit card company again.

And the ripple effect? “We’re helping other families set up the same system,” Brandon shares. “Even my mother-in-law has a policy on my son! She’s paying for it, not us.” That’s multigenerational thinking in action.

Building Legacy With Purpose and Simplicity

Ask most people what legacy means, and you’ll get poetic answers about yachts, generational wealth, and beach houses. But for Brandon:

Legacy is practical and deeply personal.

“I want my son to understand how money works,” he says plainly. That’s why his son, at just seven years old, is already in an investing club with his mom. He’s learning about compound interest, the value of saving, and the basics of stewardship not by theory, but by example.

“We teach him the 10-10-10 rule,” Brandon explains. “Tithe 10%, save 10%, and live on the rest.” It’s a principle pulled from faith and reinforced through practice. “Most people are sleepwalking,” he warns again.

“But policies force you to live deliberately.”

This idea of “overflow” permeates everything. From date nights that prioritize their marriage to banking meetings that anchor their family in shared values, the Neelys walk the talk.

“Marriage comes before business,” Brandon insists. “And out of that overflow, we can do so much more.”

Their approach isn’t complicated. It’s clear, intentional, and replicable. And that’s exactly what makes it powerful. Legacy isn’t about wealth alone—it’s about values that endure.

Faith, Principles, and the Power of Proximity

In a world obsessed with hustle culture, Brandon stands as a quiet rebel. He’s not chasing the next tactic. He’s grounded in timeless principles—faith, stewardship, generosity, and integrity.

Much of his philosophy draws from Nelson Nash, the father of Infinite Banking. “Nelson talked about principles, not just tactics,” Brandon says. “And he always warned,

‘Don’t deviate from your principles. The first deviation is the hardest, but each one after that gets easier.”

This conviction keeps Brandon anchored, especially as his income grows. “Contentment is the antidote to the arrival syndrome,” he says.

That’s why he tithes regularly, gives above and beyond during church campaigns, and keeps “humility” tattooed on his arm as a reminder.

It’s also why he surrounds himself with people who sharpen his thinking. Whether it’s family banking meetings with Nelson’s book at the center or attending the Think Tank conference with 300 financial professionals, Brandon believes that who you’re around shapes what you believe is possible.

That’s not just a theory. It’s the reason his son believes in giving, even before he fully understands ETFs or compounding. “Kids watch what you do, not what you say,” Brandon points out. “Make sure what you’re doing reflects the legacy you want to leave.”

Creating Financial Systems That Support Real Life

Most people think financial planning is just about the numbers—budgets, spreadsheets, retirement projections. But Brandon Neely sees it differently. For him, financial systems must reflect the reality of your life, not some perfect, static plan.

“Our policies, our Profit First setup, it all flows with our actual needs,” Brandon shares. That means factoring in things like their child’s future, caring for aging parents, and even maintaining a strong marriage.

“I’ve been married 18 years, and my mother-in-law has lived with us for 12,” he says. “She’s got a policy, too—on my son. She’s funding it, so it doesn’t touch our cash flow.”

This layered approach makes money feel more human and more useful. You’re not just following formulas, you’re building a system that breathes with your family’s rhythms. And because of that, Brandon insists that real wealth planning includes “marriage date nights” just as much as bank reconciliations.

The Neelys also integrate the Entrepreneurial Operating System (EOS) into their lives, which helps balance roles. “I’m more the visionary. Amanda’s the integrator,” Brandon says. “When things get complex, she steps in. She’s the CFP.” That’s a crucial distinction for families or couples who want to co-lead without chaos.

Define your strengths. Share the mission. Stick to your values. Then build systems that help you live them out.

At the end of the day, your money should serve your life, not the other way around. Brandon’s story proves that when you design your financial systems with real life in mind, you’re not just building wealth. You’re building freedom.

Conclusion

Brandon Neely’s story isn’t about luck. It’s about aligning cash flow with vision, principles with action, and money with mission.

He didn’t start with wealthy parents, a trust fund, or investor backing. He started with credit card debt, a flooded café, and a hunger for something better. Through tools like Profit First and Infinite Banking, he found a way to turn chaos into clarity—not just for his family, but for every client he now serves.

If you’re tired of sleepwalking through your financial life, it’s time to wake up. You are your biggest investment. And the most powerful wealth system isn’t found on Wall Street—it’s built in your own home, one deliberate decision at a time.

For more information, watch the full episode here and grab a copy of Don’t Spread the Wealth. Discover how to make the infinite banking concept work for you.

ORDER A COPY OF OUR NEW BOOK!

Don’t Spread the Wealth: How to Leverage the Family Banking System to Own All the Gold, Make the Rules, and Enjoy Generational Riches https://www.amazon.ca/Dont-Spread-Wealth-Leverage-Generational-ebook/dp/B0CW19QSGT/

Website: https://dontspreadwealth.com/

🎙️ WEALTH ON MAIN STREET LINKS:

Learn how Canadians are Implementing Infinite Banking for Free Here:

https://www.ascendantfinancial.ca/ibc-wwbs/?LeadSourceId=427

Podcast Website: https://wealthwithoutbaystreet.com/

Subscribe to our Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj8ZlieHodxhD0vC75-rq0g

Book a 15-minute call: https://www.ascendantfinancial.ca/schedule/?LeadSourceId=427

Watch our Tribute To The Man Who Created Infinite Banking R. Nelson Nash here:

https://dayofnelson.com/day

🤝 Join Our Community! https://www.facebook.com/groups/wealthwithoutbaystreet/

📚 IBC RECOMMENDED BOOKS